Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, issued a €805 million ($886 million) penalty against Meta on Saturday for unlawfully accessing user photographs and videos without obtaining explicit consent or providing adequate notice. The sanction ranks among the most substantial penalties ever imposed by the Italian regulator.
The enforcement action targeted Meta's Facebook platform, specifically the company's "camera roll" suggestions feature introduced in 2023. This functionality allowed the platform to scan Android users' photo galleries to propose content enhancements using personal images and videos. Beyond visual files, the regulator determined that Facebook also accessed associated metadata.
According to the Garante's investigation, Meta obtained user permission through a single authorization that "applies across the entire app covering multiple features with different requirements." The permission request was preceded by a "non-specific notice" designed to enable additional functions, which failed to clarify that users were authorizing camera roll recommendations. The regulator further found that the feature operated in an enabled state by default.
When given in full, such permission allows the app to access the entire photo library on the device, usually on a permanent basis, without the user or [regulators] being able to verify what information is actually being used
Garante press release
The Garante determined that this practice breached Italian data protection law protecting "the smartphone as part of the individual's private sphere." The regulator stated that accessing data stored on such devices demands "free and informed consent, regardless of whether data is transmitted or any harm occurs."
Meta contested the Garante's authority to levy the fine, but the regulator rejected this objection. While Meta did not immediately respond to requests for comment, the company told other media outlets that it firmly opposes the decision and intends to challenge what it characterized as a "disproportionate" penalty amount.
The enforcement comes as Meta faces mounting legal challenges globally. In October, a U.S. court ordered the company to pay $25 billion for misleading consumers regarding its data usage practices, among other recent court defeats.
Beyond the monetary penalty, the Garante mandated that Meta implement specific changes within 60 days. These requirements include obtaining authorization through a "separate and specific" request for the feature with transparent explanations of its purpose, and switching the option to disabled by default.
The magnitude of the fine reflects several aggravating factors: approximately 20 million Italian Android users were affected, the violation persisted over an extended period, and Meta demonstrated insufficient cooperation throughout the investigation, according to the regulator's statement.



