Negotiations are underway between the European Parliament and Council on two legislative proposals governing communications service providers, encompassing those operating satellite networks. Within these texts, the Commission has sought to secure authority to mandate invasive surveillance measures—chiefly data retention and interception—against satellite operators via non-transparent mechanisms. EDRi, a digital rights coalition, and its member organisations are pushing back, urging lawmakers to protect fundamental rights and uphold the EU's standards for transparent policymaking.

Concerns over unaccountable Commission powers

EDRi and allied groups have written to Parliament and the Council expressing alarm at proposals to embed unlawful data retention mandates into EU authorisation procedures for satellite operators under the Digital Networks Act (DNA) and Mobile Satellite Services (MSS) Regulation frameworks.

The concern centres on a specific mechanism: through comitology procedures—committees operating largely behind closed doors—the Commission could unilaterally impose data retention and interception requirements on satellite operators and set their parameters. This arrangement grants the Commission discretionary authority that circumvents key democratic safeguards and risks serious consequences for privacy and data protection rights.

The timing compounds the problem. The Commission is currently reviewing the broader impacts of data retention as part of deliberations on whether a fresh EU legal framework is needed. Introducing data retention obligations through the DNA and MSS proposals during this assessment period is premature and contradictory.

Established jurisprudence from the Court of Justice of the European Union has already settled the matter: blanket retention of traffic and location data constitutes a grave breach of fundamental rights and cannot be justified as a preventive crime-fighting tool under EU law.