A diplomatic initiative spearheaded by Britain and France secured agreement from fourteen governments on Wednesday on the first set of guidelines governing the commercial spyware industry. The Pall Mall Process, designed to constrain the worldwide market for surveillance capabilities, produced these standards at its third conference.
The French Foreign Ministry characterized the guidelines as "the first global standard of responsible conduct" in response to the spread of commercial cyber intrusion capabilities (CCICs). The ministry noted that "access to certain capabilities once reserved for a handful of specialized government agencies has gradually widened: any actor can now buy 'off the shelf' the ability to silently penetrate a phone."
Though governments have deployed such tools in intelligence work and law enforcement operations against organized crime, the ministry warned that "they have also been implicated in surveillance campaigns targeting journalists, political officials, activists or businesses."
What the guidelines require
The guidelines are voluntary commitments endorsed by governments rather than industry bodies. They establish expectations for vendors, distributors and financiers of surveillance technology to screen buyers, implement technical protections against misuse and establish mechanisms for tracking and disclosing abuses.
- Halt sales and support when credible risk of serious misuse exists
- Vet customers before providing access to tools
- Establish technical safeguards against misuse
- Maintain systems for monitoring and reporting abuses
- "Consider" remedies for victims of human rights violations
No enforcement mechanisms or penalties accompany the guidelines. Instead, pressure to comply is expected to come from governments that purchase the tools and control their export licensing.
The British Foreign Office stated the guidelines aim "to disincentivise irresponsible activity across the market for CCICs; improve transparency for regulators, vendors and customers; and provide clarity for businesses operating both within and peripherally to the industry."
Limited uptake among participating nations
Representatives from 43 countries attended the Pall Mall Process conference, but fewer than half chose to endorse the new guidelines. Signatories included the United Kingdom, France, the United States, Germany, Italy and Japan. The remaining fifteen nations that attended did not formally back the standards, though the reasons remain unclear.
The French ministry stressed that "the guidelines are voluntary in nature. They do not create new international legal obligations and do not call into question uses that states consider legitimate in the fields of national security, defense, the fight against organized crime or cybersecurity." However, it added: "A voluntary code is not, however, an optional code: one's word, given before one's peers, one's industries and one's citizens, is a commitment."
Persistent challenges for the initiative
The Pall Mall Process, launched in London in 2024, has encountered ongoing obstacles. The inaugural conference attracted major technology and cybersecurity firms but notably excluded the controversial vendors whose products have been documented in abuse cases.
By the second conference a year later, participants expressed doubts about whether the initiative possessed sufficient leverage to reshape how these tools are marketed and deployed. Critics also pointed out that Britain and France appeared to be restricting other nations' access to surveillance technology while simultaneously promoting their own spyware sectors.
The previous conference produced a code of practice for governments, which has since been signed by twenty-seven countries. However, that gathering failed to generate consensus on mechanisms to shape corporate behavior.
Looking ahead, the French ministry indicated that participants would pursue further work as "artificial intelligence, the growing automation of certain functions and the emergence of new business models" create fresh challenges for both state and commercial actors.



